HThe Homeowner Rights ProjectA coalition formed by New York Homeowners Alliance

The Homeowner Rights Project

The Lawsuit

The federal case for homeowner rights.

Living document

This complaint is a living document. Counts are being added as the legal strategy develops. This page reflects the most current draft as of the date above.

Primary Source

Complaint โ€” Draft

Published January 2026 ยท Updated March 2026

The full text of the draft complaint will appear here. Until it is uploaded to this archive, the below summary reflects the claims currently pled in the working draft. The final filed version will be posted in full and version-tracked below.

The complaint names the City of New York as defendant. This case is built on Fourth, Eighth, and Fourteenth Amendment claims โ€” warrantless searches and inspections of private homes, fines designed for commercial operators applied to ordinary homeowners, and due process and equal protection concerns in how the law is enforced. Relief sought is declaratory and injunctive. These are only some of the arguments at the center of this case; we're not detailing every claim publicly while the litigation is still being finalized.

For the plain-language explainer, see Case Overview.

Version history

  1. v1 โ€” 6 counts

    Initial draft โ€” Fourth, Eighth, and Fourteenth Amendment claims, among others.

    January 2026